9 Comments

Melinda, I'm so glad Howard chose this. The Tree of Life was my own childhood synagogue. I had my bat mitzvah there. This essay is dear to my heart. Thank you for letting us run it.

Expand full comment

I’m humbled by the personal connections both you and Howard had to my story, but then again, I also can’t be surprised. We are all family—mishpacha.

Expand full comment

I was in Pittsburgh that weekend, visiting my son, who was a student at Pitt. It was surreal.

Expand full comment

Here I am too! Thank you!

Expand full comment

Gorgeous and remarkably insightful. I remember the first time i comprehended that without the holocaust I would not have existed. I was very young. Already then I was struck with how statistically unlikely my life was. But it has taken me time to come to gratitude more so than the weight and guilt that I am here (hineni). Thank you for the wisdom 🙏

Expand full comment

I loved this piece, it’s a wonderful choice for the first nonfiction essay.

Expand full comment

Hineni! Melinda, your writing is always so on point and gorgeous!

Expand full comment

Here we are. Thank you, Melinda, Howard, Elissa.

Expand full comment

So beautifully done; thank you for sharing Melinda!

Expand full comment